Friday, May 11, 2012

Course evaluation - notes to self that may bore others


Last Tuesday was the final meeting of my literature class. I drove home wishing I had prepared a farewell speech, but I was so happy that all I had to do was prepare a final exam that I didn’t spend any time thinking about what I might say to the students as a valedictory. Fortunately, one of the kids had made chocolate chocolate chip cookies, so I wished them luck with their future studies, handed them their tests, and told them to help themselves to cookies if they needed a sugar pick-me-up.

Fortunately, the week before I had taken a little bit of time to thank the students for coming and asking them about how they thought the class went.  No course evaluations here, and the students seemed satisfied with the classroom experience they received for the price of their tuition. In fact, they were quite kind.  Some asked me to keep in touch. They asked after my family and talked about theirs. They said they now were interested in poetry and would read more. A couple of students still didn’t pass the class because they didn’t turn in their papers, but for the most part they were more attentive, more personally involved, and more intent on doing well than the students I had my first semester back in the classroom last year.  I don’t know if it was just this group of students or if it is the culture, and the fact that most of these students were also working and probably paying their own way.

My own attitude at the end of the semester is quite different that first experience at the community college in Mississippi, when I passed out the course evaluations with a shudder.  Generally this class flowed pretty smoothly.  My flaws: talking too much, not coming up with interactive/entertaining class plans, spending too much time introducing the class’s topic and not enough time on the topic. This is because I often thought more about what I was going to talk about than about what I was actually going to say.

Another stumbling block: few students actually did the reading. For poetry, this wasn’t too much of a problem, but for the short story unit, we didn’t have time to read the story in class.  A couple of times, I actually did have some plans for discussions, but if few or none of the students had read the story, there wasn’t any discussing. I was always hoping I wouldn’t have to do all the talking.

Successes: The drama unit went pretty well when I had them perform; they especially enjoyed paraphrasing Shakespeare. The best short story classes were the first class when we talked about folk tales and fables, and they told me some Chamorro legends, and the class dedicated to setting when I had them write their own description of their favorite place. They all really liked O’Henry’s “The Gift of the Magi,” which made me realize I need to pick a few more uplifting tales, despite Flannery O’Connor’s injunctions. No one cared for “Young Goodman Brown” and although “Harrison Bergeron” got people talking a little bit, hardly any students liked the story. It felt too flat.

That students like sentimentality was obvious in the poetry unit also. Multiple students wrote about Tony Hoagland’s poem “Beauty” because it was easily accessible and had an obvious message about beauty being what’s on the inside.  I chose the poem to illustrate differences in diction, even though I can’t say it’s one of my favorites.  I never did get around to talking about “The Lovesong of J. Alfred Prufrock” even though it’s so handy for talking about figurative devices. I had it on the syllabus, but after rereading it, I was afraid that much of the imagery and nuances would mean little to my students. The descriptions of city life and ennui just seemed too foreign for this crowd. They enjoyed Frost’s “Two Roads Diverged,” despite the fact that the woods are always green, never yellow, here, but they didn’t have anything to say about some of the religious poems – John Donne’s “Batter My Heart,” Herbert’s “Easter Wings,” Hopkins’ “Pied Beauty.” But I’ll keep them on the syllabus next semester, nonetheless.

While teaching in Mississippi, I feared I was repeating what many students had learned in high school, but this semester, I gathered that few, if any, of the regularly anthologized works were familiar to the students. Everything was new. This made my job easier in some ways and harder in others.  I really should have spent some time teaching how to write a thesis statement. That lesson would have paid off.

And although it pains me to have to cut the number of poets, I think it would be better to focus on just a handful of poems that exemplify either a particular form, figurative speech, or a particular style. Let’s say we spend 6-8 weeks on poetry, with 2 classes a week. Probably 3 poems are max we can cover well in an hour and half.  So what are the best 36-48 poems for introducing poetry to the over 18 crowd?

That’s my challenge over the summer. That, and organizing notes, and keeping the kids safe, fed, clean, catechized, and occasionally intellectually challenged, while running around the island, and possibly taking a trip somewhere.

No comments:

Reading is one form of escape. Running for your life is another.
-Lemony Snicket