The school year officially ended on Thursday. We have been winding down for a couple of weeks, but the schools let out after a party Thursday morning. My eighth grader, who had a 5th grade promotion ceremony, a 6th grade promotion ceremony, has had an 8th grade promotion ceremony. Meanwhile none of the other kids has ever had any promotion ceremony. But the eighth grader has been to home school, a public elementary, 3 different private elementaries, a private junior high, a department of defense elementary, and now he will go to an 8th school next year.
The big question is where will that be.
I have been wrestling with education issues for the last couple of weeks and have not reached a resolution.
All year I’ve heard complaints about the DOD schools. Nothing major at the elementary, except complaints about particular teachers, but at the high school marijuana and spice use are rampant and the level of expectation is low. My ninth grader spent most of 4th quarter reading novels in his biology class because the teacher gave the other students time to finish the homework they hadn't done for the previous quarter. And he spent a good portion of his honors literature class studying an obscure civilization in Peru that left behind no written work because the teacher assigned each student a different ancient culture to study for the semester. His final essay topic was to discuss job specialization and the development of religious beliefs and central governments in ancient cultures. Nothing about literature. But he did read Romeo and Juliet.
Meanwhile, all year at home with my home schoolers, I’ve heard complaints about doing work. No surprise, but when our test scores were returned a couple weeks ago, I realized even though I’ve tried to keep up with teaching the kids, they aren’t getting the motivation or instruction that I was hoping to give them. On top of that, the behavior of the 7 year old has spiraled downward all year, so that I’m concerned about his wellbeing.
So when a friend passed on the word that one of the private schools on the island was seeking a middle school English teacher, I sent in my resume. This is one of the best schools on the island. It is Episcopalian, and a fundamentalist friend told me it was liberal, but I took that opinion with a grain of salt. It is primarily attended by Japanese and Korean students.
I just returned home from a second interview. I haven’t been offered the job, but I need to have an answer ready if it is offered.
On the one hand, it seems too good to be true: I’d get a small salary that would cover the discounted tuition rate the kids would receive. I am convinced that the academics are superior to the DOD school, and it is a Christian school rather than secular (although this could be a negative). I like the idea of the kids getting to know kids from other countries. I like the emphasis on community service and the arts at this school.
But my kids don’t want to go. They want to go where their friends from the neighborhood go. They want to have the opportunity to play football and rugby, which aren’t offered at the private school.
But I have questions about some of their friends, especially some of the ones who play football.
But I have questions about some of their friends, especially some of the ones who play football.
My husband and I are both concerned about the impact my working would have on family time, although I would be teaching at least one of my kids.
We are also concerned that this would limit our ability to travel, although we haven’t done much yet anyway.
I have already agreed to teach a class at the community college next semester.
I doubt that we would integrate much with the other families at the new school, since I would have to keep a professional distance. Our neighborhood and church communities are on the base. Time to develop those friendships would be limited.
There is something to be said for going to school close to home.
I would not be able to take advantage of hiking and field trips during the week, although those opportunities were rare.
We would lose contact with our home school friends.
I would give up the ideals I had for home schooling, which we never realized.
I would gain professional experience if I wanted to apply to teach at our next duty station, where DOD schools aren't available.
The kids would have to undergo another transition. But something needs to change with our current home schooling situation.
I would have a lot of prep work. I would enjoy that prep work.
I would have to wake up earlier and go to bed earlier.
My husband would be sad if I spent too much time doing prep work and not enough time with him. He doesn't mind cooking, but I know he wouldn't be thrilled if the laundry piled up even higher.
My mind keeps circling. On the one hand,a good education for our kids is one of the priorities we've held dear up until this point. We've believed that it's something worth making sacrifices for. At the same time, we've also worked hard to maintain strong family unity by making time for family activities, dinner together, and parental presence at extra-curriculars. With the instability of the military lifestyle, we've tried to make these things constants. But if I'm working, my participation could be compromised, even though I'd try my darnedest to limit incursions on sancrosanct family events.
I want the best for my kids. But I can't figure out what that is right now. Part of me wants to take the easy route, send the kids to the DOD school and forget about whether they can get into a great college or whether they watch a lot of movies at school, just so they are happy. I always intend to supplement their education at home, but these good intentions sometimes get shuffled to the bottom of the priority list.
The other part of me wants to be a little of a tiger mom and put in the effort and make the sacrifices that working would require so that they are challenged academically. Plus I would like the challenge of teaching. At one point in my life, I thought I'd be doing something just like this - teaching at the school where my kids attended. Am I letting my own dream inform my decision about what's best for the kids and the family?
I've never been very good at seeing things in black and white. Too many shades of gray.

4 comments:
Prayers from a lurker. I am convinced more and more that many times there isn't one perfectly right answer. We work on the state of our hearts, and we work to trust God with our concerns.
Belssings.
Your situation is more complicated than mine, but the school decision is tough here, too. The 9th grader had a dismal year at the well-regarded public HS in our neighborhood. Dropped from Alg II/Trig down to Alg II after the first quarter, and still ended up with a D for the year. Rather than hanging out with the bright IB and Honors students, he gravitates towards the neighborhood slackers -- hanging around 7-11, some petty vandalism, a bit of pot once in a while. The irony is that this child has always been a huge reader, and interested in everything. He can talk about history, philosophy and politics for hours; but is not interested in school, and has a C average in his classes. He seems like a fit for an independent, self-directed home-schooling education, but we have big doubts about our ability to educate him. Prayers for you.
Lurkers, welcome! I appreciate the prayers. Same for you both. Kelly, you're right - there isn't a perfect answer. And really, each of our choices has a good side. Margaret, you're not alone in having kids that gravitate towards slackers. One good thing about moving often is getting to leave those types behind.
One good thing in all the difficulty of decision-making is that your children can see that you take their schooling and upbringing very seriously, enough that you struggle over these things every year, because you love them.
And no matter their current test scores, I believe that the example and nurturing of their parents and home environment, even your less-than-perfect homeschooling (which continues after hours) is giving them a true education, the passing on of a culture and a tradition.
Post a Comment