1 . For people interested in words, here is a charmingly illustrated list of words that are untranslatable into English. Be sure to read the comments for more.
2. Here's another page sure to please people who like words: a defense of English majors. Not terribly different than the one from the Chronicle, this one is from the New Yorker by Adam Gopnik. My favorite line: "A good doctor said to me, not long ago, “You really sort of have to like assholes and ear wax to be a good general practitioner”; you have to really like, or not mind much, intricate and dull and occasionally even dumb arguments about books to study English."
3. I wish there were such a thing as a grammar major. I guess that would be in the composition department, or perhaps I should go back to school to a get a foreign language degree so I could do translations and think about grammatical forms and phraseology. I've been pleased lately that my sophomore is doing grammar, which he hasn't done for 2 or 3 years at his other schools. I get sort of excited about talking about gerunds and participles or reflexive pronouns. I have to prevent myself from doing his homework. I particularly like when he gets a tricky example.
4. That New Yorker article is a pat on the back to people who like to read. No one is likely to be offended by it. The article from the New York Times Magazine that my sister linked to is irritating and on the edge of being offensive because it's divisive. "The Opt-Out Generation Wants Back In" by Judith Warner is yet another gauntlet thrown into the stay-at-home moms vs. working moms battle. Why is this a battle? Because authors like Warner make it sound like an all or none choice. She is deliberately stirring up discontent and anxiety by encouraging moms to worry about whether or not they can find employment after staying home for a few years. Did the women interviewed think they could step right back into the workforce after 10 or more years of absence and earn the same amount? Aside from the fact that they might have expected to start back at reduced pay, they don't give much attention to the fact that we're in a recession and many people are earning less than they used to. How many of these women would have "risen to the top" if they had stayed in their professions? There is only so much space up there. There is also only a brief mention that many of the women didn't like the jobs they left, and they get more job satisfaction from their new jobs. Additionally, how many of them are working the same number of hours? Even if their kids are in school, their kids still have a lot of needs that limit the amount of working hours moms can reasonably carry without hiring help.
This article also bugs me because it promotes the "what about me?" attitude, which I know we all suffer from. I hate sweeping floors, too. I hate doing laundry. But someone has to do it. And when we do it as an act of love and service, it's easier to get past the poor me's. When you love someone, you want to make them comfortable and happy. When you love yourself, you want to make yourself comfortable and happy and admired and well compensated. I'm not saying all these women are selfish. But the article is definitely not written from a perspective of Christian community. Why is it that the volunteer jobs mentioned all have to do with fundraising for elite private schools instead of soup kitchens or literacy programs or Meals on Wheels or beach clean-ups or whatever?
The article obviously got under my skin because I still struggle with the desire to do something besides just be a stay at home mom, and I'm having trouble finding that something here in California, partly because of my health condition and partly because of the schedule at the kids' schools and partly because of availability. I'm one of those unemployed English majors. In my day, English majors were legion. So now there are no open positions for English adjuncts at the three closest branches of the community college. And because I want to be available to volunteer at my kids' school and help them with their homework, I really don't want a full time or full attention job. My teaching and volunteer work in Guam satiated a desire to feel useful and to practice doing things I loved. I don't care that I'm not making thousands; I just want an outlet for my desire to teach that wasn't fulfilled by home schooling. So now I'm looking into other options for English majors that won't earn me millions and will allow me to continue to be present for my kids in the afternoons and to make them cookies and muffins or at least get their laundry washed during the week.
5. Finished another YA book that my 11 yr old just read: Esperanza Rising by Pam Munoz Ryan. Recommended. Kind of a cross between Caramelo and The Grapes of Wrath for the preteen. The story of a young Mexican girl whose family loses its wealth when her father dies, so she and her mother have to immigrate to California with their servants and work as farmhands. Simply told - the suffering described in The Grapes of Wrath is minimized and the value of family and friends is heightened without the drama of Caramelo. My daughter loved it, and I'm happy she read something about a difficult period of history with a heroine who struggled against selfishness and learned to work hard for pennies to help her family survive.
6. We also both read Al Capone Does My Shirts by Gennifer Choldenko. Another unintentional California read, this time set in San Francisco. A likable story about a boy living on Alcatraz whose life is complicated by his sister's special needs. My quibble: sometimes books that are semi-historical fiction seem a little forced when contemporary issues are appended.
7. http://www.theguardian.com/books/2013/sep/02/seamus-heaney-last-words-funeral Seamus Heaney's last words: "Noli timere" texted to his wife. Love it. Requiescat in pace.
Elections and Meaning
1 day ago

4 comments:
+JMJ+
I like the idea of reading "California books" in California. =) Of course, anyone with a reading habit will eventually read books set where he lives, but in your family's case, there seems to be an additional, timely effect of helping you feel settled in to your new home. Were Esperanza Rising and Al Capone Does My Shirts selected for the California settings or were they totally serendipitous?
Emily, what you've said about wanting an outlet for your desire to teach that wasn't fulfilled by homeschooling is very haunting to me. If you could design your dream job, what kind of teaching would you be doing?
Both Esperanza Rising and Al Capone Does My Shirts were totally serendipitous. The Al Capone book was at the library and the Esperanza book was one I had picked up a few years ago that my daughter never read until we were unpacking book boxes during move-in. But I reread Grapes of Wrath on purpose, and I'm thinking about getting into some Wallace Stegner soon.
The teaching vs. home schooling thing is an interesting quandary. I can't really explain it to my husband either. Maybe it is an age thing - I like teaching older kids and adults who read the books I want to read and talk about. With the younger kids at home, I had trouble getting excited about doing math facts myself, so I'm sure I didn't convey a great sense of loving to learn math to them. I do love reading with them, but I hated the daily battles to do math or the glazed over uninterested look when it came to reading history or trying to get them to do a history project. I had a hard time getting into craft projects to make learning "fun" and I also had trouble keeping the attention of my own kids and keeping them motivated. Maybe the kids and I both "perform" better when we are working in front of someone outside of the family.
"My Dream Job" is another hard question! I've toyed with the idea of going back to school to get a teaching certificate to teach at a high school but based on my experience subbing, I don't think I'd enjoy the every day from 8-4 job with students who don't want to be there and the discipline issues. I don't want to be constantly trying to keep up with kids and cell phones. I really enjoyed being at the community college in Guam where the students seemed motivated, and I had time between classes to try to come up with lectures that would spark some conversation or "aha" moments. I wasn't always successful at that, and I struggled a bit teaching composition - probably focused too much on grammar because it's teachable (and necessary for some students), but at least I enjoyed doing the research. I almost took a job after graduating from college at a small private high school that taught a great books program and had seminar format classes, and sometimes I wonder if we'll ever live in a place with a similar school. It probably would have been a great place to work. What about you? What would your dream job be?
+JMJ+
Right now, I'm teaching English as a Second Language to adults, as part of a corporate training package. It's a good gig, combining grammar (which, yes, is totally teachable!) with discussions of a great variety of topics. But there are rarely any of those "Aha!" moments that come from discussing something like literature. I'm like a personal trainer who designs workouts and provides encouragement every step of the way; but what my clients choose to do with their new skills is their business.
Of course, the trade off is that the learners want to be having lessons, so there are no disciplinary issues like what you'd have in a school.
I'd say that my dream job is homeschooling . . . or barring that, teaching in set-up as close to the little red schoolhouse as possible. I don't like it when classrooms are teacher-centric, if only because I know what my limitations are and don't want those to be the classroom's limitations as well. Like you, for instance, I'm not great at crafts. But if a student happened to be really crafty, and even artistic, I wouldn't mind letting him or her take the lead in a class project. Since the idea might never even occur to me, I'd even want him to pitch it! (Is this asking too much, though?) I would love for my real task to be the creation and maintenance of an environment in which learning is encouraged and easy to do.
One of the managers at my office loves to remind us to make our lessons as collaborative as possible--and to point out that our company's training model was designed to give the learners as much say in choosing the direction of their learning as the trainers get. Structure is available for those who want it; but anyone who wants the freedom to try something else can have that, too. I love this about my job and wish such a model were available in traditional classrooms as well.
Sounds like you have a pretty good set-up right now - Corporate work probably pays well! And your manager sounds great, too. Collaboration was something else that I liked about the community college - I could change directions based on what the students wanted and needed in class, especially in the composition class. I could change the readings based on the interests of the class (in composition class, where we read essays and selections for examples of how to write - not in the lit class, although I changed a few stories and poems based on the make up of the class, and I changed the contemporary drama to go with what the University was performing), focus on different skills, do different kinds of projects based on whether the class liked small groups or large discussions, etc, which wouldn't be an option if I decided to teach in a traditional school with a set curriculum and standards that had to be covered.
I love the little red schoolhouse concept, too - which again reminds me of the community college, which had age diversity in class. Especially in my lit class, the older students would mentor and give good examples and connections to life while being invigorated by the younger students who came up with the interactive group projects and connections with music and film. In my composition class, the older students were maybe a little harder to assist because they were more set in their ways of writing, but they were great for ideas and content. And to relate that to my own kids' school experiences - we've definitely been happiest when they have been in small schools with interaction between the classes. Our best homeschooling years were when we were in Virginia, and we were part of a co-op. I loved teaching in the co-op where at different times I taught science to middle schoolers, Latin to kids ages 8-15, and British Lit to a group ranging in age from a mature 12 year old to 18. The kids loved it, too, and as a part of a group, they were more motivated to absorb what they were reading and put more effort into their composition and home work. My boys especially thrived on competition.
I do love the idea of home schooling, but I wasn't able to be the inspirational facilitator of a love of learning and independent inquiry that I wanted to be, and often felt more like a nag taking all of the fun out of everything. Maybe I should have backed off, found something else of interest to them, or been more of an unschooler, but those modes weren't easy for me. And although I know there are parents who do fabulous things and find great opportunities for their kids at home, I didn't have the time/energy/ingenuity to get my kids into the things that they have been able to participate in through school, like the state geography bee, the national ecybermission competition, model United Nations, and a Linguafest in Japan. I haven't ruled out home schooling again in the future if we were living in a place where it would be easy or necessary to do so, but right now I'm happy with the way their school days are going. They are in a tiny Catholic school with lots of parent involvement (both a positive and a negative) and what seems to be a pretty solid curriculum. We'll see how we feel after a few months!
Post a Comment