Short article on children's literature that is starting conversations:
http://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2013/dec/03/childrens-books-great-literature-university-of-kent-sf-said
A quick link because I don't have much time or much to say. I just read
Wonder by R. J. Palacio on the advice of my eighth grader, and now my 4th and 6th graders are reading it. It's the popular new novel about a boy with a facial deformity. After I read the ending, I was reminded of a debate a friend from graduate school got into with a guy in line at Blockbuster. We had checked out and were waiting for 15 minutes before she left the discussion. They were debating the merits/demerits of
Mr. Holland's Opus, or "Doofus" as my friend called it because of its sentimentality and maudlin ending.
Wonder might be accused of the same thing. It's a book with a social conscience about this boy who is going to school for the first time in middle school because he's had so many surgeries during his life. Is it great literature or would the original author of the U of Kent course description mentioned above dismiss it as akin to mass-market thrillers? According to the author of this article, SF Said, great literature is something that affects your beliefs and changes the world:
"And yet, by every criterion listed, children's fiction is entirely capable of being great literature. Indeed, if you're looking for writing that changes the reader and the world, there may be no better form. I work with the CLPE (Centre For Literacy in Primary Education). I've visited countless schools and seen for myself the life-changing power of children's books. It's impossible to overstate the transformative effects they can have upon individual readers – and collectively, across generations, upon the world."
It's always hard to come up with a definition of great literature. I also finished another Anthony Trollope book,
Can You Forgive Her, and enjoyed it more than the first. It certainly isn't transformative, but could you make the argument that it is better literature than
Wonder? Technically, at least, you could posit that Trollope is a better writer than Palacio. But
Wonder will affect more people more strongly than Trollope's work, which does drag on. My friend may scoff at the happy ending and my sister might argue that the world of middle school is too gently portrayed, but I'm happy to let my kids enjoy
Wonder since I enjoyed reading it myself. A feelgood story is medicinal every now and then.
PS: Notes on our recent feast:
We had a nice Thanksgiving with elderly neighbors, young sailors, the cousins and the cousin's visiting friends. A nice mix of people who barely knew each other. The food was delicious, and some new taste preferences were discovered: I like mashed potatoes with cauliflower; my husband was appalled at the break with tradition. Yellow sweet potatoes are better than orange yams, or maybe it's the other way around. Yellow yams? Sweet potato (or yam) pie is sweeter and probably more nutritious than pumpkin pie, and since no one trusted sweet potato, I got to eat most of it myself. Macaroons are an Italian tradition that I would like to eat more often. The brined turkey turned out just as moist and maybe tastier than the turkey cooked in the oilless turkey fryer, which is really more of a convection cooker, but the oillessly fried turkey cooked in only 2 hours and was very tasty. Also the stuffing inside the brined turkey was really too salty. My great-grandmother's recipe for cloverleaf rolls are still a hit, so I should triple the recipe to have any leftover. And there is no better way to use up leftover pie crust and gravy than turkey potpie.
These photos are from the cousin's house. My house is not so colorful and stylish and lacks backyard water access.
 |
| Desserts |
 |
| Appetizers and Thanksgiving book. Note oldest son taking out paddle board pre-meal. |
 |
| Side dishes. Somehow I never got a photo of the turkeys |
 |
| But this is a portrait of my stomach taken by one of the kids post TG meal. Plus a 22 week old baby. |