I powered through several books in December, enabled by some lucky library finds, internet recommendations, and a long car trip. I hope to get around to writing about a few here.
The book I keep thinking about is Melody Warnick's
This Is Where You Belong: The Art and Science of Loving the Place You Live. I found it at our library after reading a review on the
Modern Mrs. Darcy blog list of "Seven books to download into your brain." It's a topic that hounds me.
The book's premise is that Warnick feels lonely and out of place in her new home of Blacksburg, VA, a place she thought would fulfill the longing for home she felt while living in Austin, TX. She reflects that she hasn't ever felt rooted to the other places where she has lived since leaving her birth place, Huntington Beach, CA. (Californians really do love their state.) She decides she is going to try to teach herself to love Blacksburg.
So she starts researching "The Lost Art of Staying Put," the title of the first chapter. In between interviews with people who stay in one place for years and people who actively try to make their homes better, known as "Place Makers," Warnick describes her own attempts to put ten precepts for becoming "place attached" into action. Reading about her efforts is motivating, although it's hard to say whether she does become rooted in Blacksburg. Her husband doesn't love his job (teaching in the English department at Virginia Tech), and at the end the book it is clear she doesn't see herself living in Blacksburg forever, although her experiment has worked in the sense that she is more fond of it and feels attached because she has met her neighbors, has a sense of Blacksburg's history, has participated in community building events, including making up a few of her own, and has walked, hiked, and biked the city and its surrounds.
Having moved 13 times, and having learned to love almost every place we've lived, I think I could have come up with the list of recommendations that Warnick devises to put into action as part of a "Love where you live" experiment, but she does the research and actively and intentionally practices them. They are:
1. Walk more
2. Buy local
3. Get to know my neighbors
4. Do fun stuff
5. Explore nature
6. Volunteer
7. Eat local
8. Become more political
9. Create something new
10. Stay loyal through hard times
I picked up the book because I find myself frequently analyzing why I don't want to stay in this vacation destination where we live. We still have a year and a half left of my husband's current orders, and we're already discussing his next request, which he'll make this spring. I'm ready to move on, but we have a daughter who will be ready to start her senior year in high school in 18 months and at least two other kids who really like it here. There may be a job here that my husband could transition into, but it requires deploying and working long hours. It would be a rewarding job for him, but we keep asking ourselves, is the stress it would put on the family worth the trade-off of the stress of moving?
If it were up to me, I'd say let's pack up and go. But I do recognize the virtues of stability for the kids, and the reality that the next place may not fulfill any of the longings for home in my heart.
Here's the thing: I do most of the 10 things Warnick recommends: 1. I walk everywhere in this town - it's only five miles around the perimeter.
2. I try to shop local and have succeeded in drastically limiting my shopping at big box stores (if you don't include the commissary and exchange and Amazon in this category).
3. I know my neighbors by name, have been to a progressive dinner with them, and actively socialize with my neighbor next door. I just took cookies to the neighbor diagonal across the street whose husband just died. He was a local who coached the surf teams and everyone's friend, a father of six, who died while surfing this week, probably of a heart attack. A real tragedy.
4.We do the fun stuff - Fourth of July parade, concerts in the park, Christmas parade, parties at the library, sand castle contests.
5. We explore nature in the surrounding area and the beach here (I'm also reading Richard Louv's new book
The Nature Principle, and my kids can tell you that I have been on a get outside tirade. Inspired by his book, and my own predilection for being outside in natural spaces, I've been itching to just spend time at a park or beach - a change for me, because usually "time in nature" means a hike, which the kids dread, although once they are moving, they are happy.)
6. We volunteer regularly with church, school, scouts, the community.
7. Although I shop mostly at the commissary, less than a mile from our house, I also try to buy produce and wine from the local market once a week. It's often less expensive, and almost always better quality, than the commissary.
8. Numbers 8 and 9 I haven't committed to: Being political is not in my nature, but I pay attention to the issues in the little local paper. Always entertaining to read the heated arguments about bike lanes and dog parks.
9. I am not particularly creative or as action-oriented as Warnick, but I did start our little co-op and a book club that is going on its third year - does that count?
10. And I am not loyal in my heart. I get swept up in the outpouring of grief in the community when someone dies, like my poor neighbor, whom I knew, or the local SEAL team members who were killed in 2016. But I feel kind of cringy when people talk about how great it is here. I want to leave.
After my husband and I had our most recent conversation about what our options are for the future, I spent some time contemplating whether someplace else might be any better. While the rest of the country is cuddled in blankets surviving the arctic blast, we have had great weather. We can be outside all year round. I love walking everywhere and not relying on big stores. We've made some good friends, and the community events are free fun for families.
But I wish our church had more for teens. The schools are fine, but not spiritually nourishing nor particularly academically challenging. I miss being a part of Catholic schools. We pay exorbitant rent and pay a premium for community sports and other activities. There's a sense of entitlement and privilege that pervades the air here. I don't know if there are any houses for sell less than a million dollars. Rents continue to go up higher than what we are paying. Our friends are mostly military people who will move eventually. We are far from extended family. I miss the highs and lows of seasonal change. I feel like someone passing through - and that's mostly because we are.
But I keep reminding myself: Someplace else might have worse schools, lack a good parish, require a car to maneuver through strip malls, and create a sense of isolation. And there's starting over again knowing it would be temporary.
So I'm trying to imagine what it would mean to end up staying here six years altogether, and then my husband retires and we pick where to live. If I continue to think of our high rent as including the premium to live someplace where we don't need an extra car, school tuition, winter gear or heating/cooling bills, or a quick trip to Target for one thing and $100 of other stuff, the financial impact seems less. Our parish has great priests, even if it doesn't have a great teen program. The emotional turmoil of uprooting everyone may cause more spiritual trauma than the lack of catechism at school. Wanting to move reflects my selfishness in craving a little dream house with a big garden and a nice kitchen. My "This is temporary" attitude is probably the biggest hindrance to loving where we live. If I can change that attitude, I would save some emotional energy and probably soften a sharp edge of resentment that I haul out every so often, usually during hormonal low times. (Is it middle age making the swing between feel good and feel bad hormones more drastic?)
Warnick's book is worth reading even if the theme is one I already know. The anecdotes she shares about other people who are making their places better and promoting where they live are entertaining and motivating. It makes me think more consciously about the adage of changing my attitude when I can't change my situation. And to a certain extent working on that consciousness - and spending more time in one place - is having an effect.